📋 Investigation Notes: The Villisca Mass Murder
- Case File: State of Iowa v. Unknown Person(s)
- Date of Discovery: Monday, June 10, 1912, at approximately 8:00 AM
- Crime Scene Location: Moore Family Residence, Villisca, Montgomery County, Iowa
- Estimated Time of Death: June 10, 1912, between 12:00 AM and 2:30 AM (Based on stomach contents and blood coagulation noted at the coroner’s inquest)
👥 Victim Ledger
The killer targeted eight individuals asleep in four beds across two floors.
First Floor (Guest Bedroom)
-
- Lena Stillinger (Age 12): Guest. Found at the foot of the bed. Only victim found with defensive wounds on her arm and a distinct positioning suggesting she awoke during the attack.
- Ina Stillinger (Age 8): Guest. Found at the head of the bed, closer to the wall.
Second Floor (Master Bedroom)
-
- Josiah “Joe” B. Moore (Age 43): Father, prominent local businessman. Suffered the most severe facial trauma. The axe head was used to strike him.
- Sara Moore (Age 39): Mother. Found in bed beside Josiah.
Second Floor (Children’s Bedroom)
- Herman Moore (Age 11): Son.
- Katherine Moore (Age 10): Daughter.
- Boyd Moore (Age 7): Son.
- Paul Moore (Age 5): Son.
🩸 Crime Scene Observations & Physical Evidence
- The Murder Weapon: A long-handled, 2-pound, single-bit axe belonging to Josiah Moore was found in the downstairs guest room where the Stillinger sisters lay. It was covered in blood but had been partially wiped down with a cloth.
- The Attic Setup: In the attic, directly above the master bedroom, investigators found two distinct indentations in the dust. They matched a human footprint and a sitting posture, indicating the killer waited there for hours while the family was at the Presbyterian Children’s Day service.
- Covered Windows & Mirrors: Every mirror in the house, along with the glass panels on the doors, had been covered with clothing and linens taken from the dressers.
- Grave-Like Cloths: The faces of all eight victims had been covered with bedsheets after they were killed.
- The Bacon Slab: A 2-pound slab of uncooked bacon wrapped in a dish towel was found on the floor of the downstairs guest room near the axe. A separate piece of bacon was found on the kitchen table.
- Unused Water Basin: A basin of bloody water was discovered on the kitchen table, suggesting the killer washed their hands before fleeing.
- The Locked House: All entry doors were locked from the inside, except for one back door which was found closed but unlocked.
🕵️ Prime Suspects Summary
- Reverend George Kelly: A traveling Presbyterian preacher who attended the Children’s Day service that night. He left town on an early morning train on June 10. He had a history of mental instability and sent bizarre letters to investigators. He signed a confession during a brutal interrogation in 1917, which he later retracted. He was tried twice: the first ended in a hung jury, and the second acquitted him.
- Frank F. Jones: A powerful Iowa State Senator and rival businessman. Josiah Moore had worked for Jones for years before opening a competing implement store, taking a lucrative John Deere contract with him. Rumors also circulated that Josiah was having an affair with Jones’s daughter-in-law.
- William “Blackie” Mansfield: A suspected hitman allegedly hired by Frank Jones to execute the Moore family. Detective James Wilkerson strongly pursued this theory. Mansfield was later linked to similar axe murders in Blue Island, Illinois, and Paola, Kansas, but he had a verifiable alibi for the night of the Villisca murders and was released.
- Andy Sawyer: A transient laborer who was arrested in Burlington, Iowa, a few days after the murders. When he boarded a train near Villisca on June 10, his clothes were muddy, and he was carrying an axe. He reportedly told people he knew details about the murders before they were public, but he was dismissed by police as a compulsive liar seeking attention.